Healthy Root Flare

Garden, Lawn & Landscape

Fall Tree Planting: Growing Healthy Trees
Means Avoiding Common
Problems at Planting

Return to:

Fall Tree Planting: Growing Healthy Trees Means Avoiding Common Problems at Planting

by Sarah Browning, UNL Extension Educator

Nebraska's climate presents a new challenge for our trees every year, including hail, wind, drought, and diseases like pine wilt. Many Nebraska trees have died in the last two years from drought. The latest threat to our trees is emerald ash borer (EAB), which has killed tens of millions of trees in twenty-four states since it's 2002 discovery in the United States. The Nebraska Forest Service expects EAB to be found somewhere in Nebraska in the next few years.

This gives us a window of opportunity, in the next few years, to begin planting new trees to replace ash trees that will be lost in years to come.

Fall is the best time of year to plant new trees, from early September through late October. Fall's cooler temperatures and increased rain allow trees to establish their root systems quickly, giving them a jump-start on spring growth. Tree root growth continues late in fall, until soil temperatures drop below 40 degrees Fahrenheit.

But growing healthy trees, that will provide beauty, shade and wind protection for your property long-term, means getting them off to a good start by avoiding common problems at planting.

What Problems?

More than ever before, tree experts know that half the battle in long-term tree success is addressing potential problems before the tree is in the ground. What problems, you ask? Isn't the tree I bought in perfect condition to be planted? Maybe. But increasingly the horticulture industry recognizes that production methods we use to grow trees in containers or in the field can cause problems for trees down the road.

The two most common production-related tree problems are stem girdling roots (SGR) and planting depth. These problems can kill a tree but they do it slowly, sometimes over the course of many years. Stem girdling roots, in particular, are often a slow killer, due to the time needed for roots to grow in diameter and begin compressing the trunk.

Both problems, unfortunately, are very common and are serious contributors to general decline in tree health. Affected trees grow slowly and are often stunted. Trees that are planted too deeply often take several years to become firm in the ground, if they ever do. Affected trees are much more susceptible to secondary stressors, like drought or pest problems, and are often attacked by insect borers. Trees are killed by these secondary problems much more easily due to their lack of vigor. During the droughts of 2012 and 2013, many trees with root problems died and continue to die in 2014.

Stem Girdling Roots
Photo of the UNL Campus

What is a stem-girdling root? Roots grow together, or graft themselves, when one root grows up against another root, IF 1) the roots are both from the same tree, or 2) from two separate trees of the same species. But, if a root grows up against or around the tree's trunk, the trunk and the root do not grow together. In this situation the root begins to compress or constrict the trunk where they touch.

How do tree production methods contribute to stem girdling roots? Most trees, whether grown from seed or cuttings, are started in pots. Roots of young trees grow quickly and if they stay too long in a small pot it's a recipe for trouble. When a root touches the side of a smooth plastic pot, it turns aside and begins to circle around the outside of the rootball. Often trees are "bumped up" from smaller pots to larger ones several times during their early years, and you have to investigate very closely to find stem girdling roots that developed when trees were young.

Believe it or not, for this reason pot technology is a major concern for tree growers with the goal of eliminating the problems caused by stem girdling roots.

Tree Planting Depth

Planting depth was not commonly recognized as a major health problem for trees until the last 20-25 years. But foresters now know that if a tree's root system is buried too deeply in the soil, overall root growth is reduced and tree health, for the rest of that tree's life, is compromised. Poor root growth can be due to several factors, including 1) lower oxygen penetration into deeper soil layers (tree roots must pull oxygen from the soil to grow properly), 2) not enough moisture in deeper soil layers, or 3) roots remain too wet in poorly drained soil.

How do tree production methods contribute to planting depth problems? When young tree whips are planted mechanically in fields, they often need to be placed deep in the soil for them to stand upright. So trees often start off too deep in the field. When they are dug and potted or balled for sale, gardeners don't realize that excess soil must be removed from the top of the root ball. Likewise, sometimes trees grown in pots are placed too deep in the soil, and if gardeners don't remove the excess the tree is doomed to planting depth problems once it's in the ground.

Ideally, when planted, the tree's first major root should be right at the soil surface and the tree's root flare (see photo at top of page) should be visible at the soil line when planting is complete.

Photo credits:

  • Root Flare Photo: Sarah Browning, UNL Extension in Lancaster County
  • Root Girdling: Joseph O'Brien, USDA Forest Service,

This resource was updated August 2014 and appeared in the Lincoln Journal Star Newspaper Sunday edition. For information on reproducing this article or using any photographs or graphics, read the Terms of Use statement

University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension in Lancaster County is your on-line yard and garden educational resource. The information on this Web site is valid for residents of southeastern Nebraska. It may or may not apply in your area. If you live outside southeastern Nebraska, visit your local Extension office

Responsive. Innovative. Trusted.