|
Alice
Henneman, MS, RD, Extension Educator & Dietitian
Linda Boeckner, PHD, RD, Extension Nutrition Specialist
Click
HERE
for FREE osteoporosis PowerPoint information
 -
"It's snowing outside and my newspaper was tossed on the bottom of the
steps -- do I dare go after it?"
 -
"I've lost six inches in height and none of my clothes
fit me anymore. Plus, it's hard to get clothes that look nice when my
back is so hunched over."
 -
"This medication is so darned expensive. But if I want
to maintain my independence, I can't afford to let my condition get worse
either."
 -
"It seemed like it took forever for my bone to heal
when it broke. I don't want that to happen again. It's so frustrating
always worrying about falling."
 -
"If somebody had told me sooner what I know now about
osteoporosis, none of this might be happening to me!"
SOURCE:
Based on comments made by a 70+ year old woman with osteoporosis.
Ten million
Americans have osteoporosis and another 18 million have low bone mass,
placing them at increased risk of osteoporosis, according to the National
Osteoporosis Foundation (NOF). Osteoporosis often is called the "silent
disease" because bone loss occurs without symptoms. The first sign of
osteoporosis may be a fracture that occurs as a result of a weakened bone.
A sudden strain or bump may be all it takes to break a bone.
Eighty
percent of those affected by osteoporosis are women. A woman’s risk of
an osteoporosis-related hip fracture equals her combined risk of breast,
uterine and ovarian cancer. Overall, one in two women and one in eight
men over 50 will have an osteoporosis-related fracture. On average, 24
percent of hip fracture patients 50 and over die during the year following
their fracture, according to NOF.
A Gallup
poll of women with osteoporosis showed few took preventive action, and
9-out-of-10 wish they had known how to take preventive measures (source:
NOF news release, May 2000).
Though
there are treatments for osteoporosis, there is currently no cure. That's
why prevention is so very important. The National Osteoporosis Foundation
recommends a combination of these four steps to help prevent osteoporosis:
- a balanced
diet rich in calcium and vitamin D;
- weight-bearing
exercise;
- a healthy
lifestyle with no smoking or excessive alcohol use; and
- bone
density testing and medications when appropriate.
Osteoporosis
is preventable for most people!
| While
osteoporosis occurs most frequently in older persons, it's important
to start building healthy bones while young. Eating a healthy diet
and leading a healthy lifestyle throughout life is important for BOTH
women and men. |
The following
information on the dietary aspects of osteoporosis is provided as information
for general healthy eating and should not be considered a substitute for
seeking dietary advice from your own health care provider. Topics covered
in this article include:
- Using
food and supplement labels to assess calcium intake;
- Percent
Daily Value for calcium in common foods;
- Additional
dietary concerns;
- Help
for the lactose-intolerant person;
- When
you don't like to "drink" milk;
- Considerations
when taking calcium supplements;
- Putting
it all together.
For additional
information about diet and osteoporosis as well as other factors influencing
bone health, two excellent resources are the National Osteoporosis Foundation
Web site <www.nof.org> and the book,
Strong Women, Strong Bones, by Miriam Nelson, PhD. (NOTE: The information
in Nelson's book is applicable to men as well as women.
Using
Food and Supplement Labels to Assess Calcium Intake
Calcium,
the major component of bones, is one of the dietary factors most frequently
mentioned in relation to osteoporosis. We can use the product label to
learn how much calcium is in packaged foods and in vitamin/mineral supplements.
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) uses the term "Percent Daily Value"
(% DV) to describe the amount of calcium a food or supplement provides
in relation to the general U.S. population's daily needs.
| NOTE:
The calcium and vitamin D recommendations in this article are based
on those developed for the United States and Canada. They may not
be appropriate for all countries due to differing dietary patterns
and environmental factors. |
The 100%
DV level for calcium equals 1,000 mg. The % DV on the "Nutrition Facts"
panel of a food label or the "Supplement Facts" section of a vitamin/mineral
supplement tells how much calcium one serving provides in relation to
1,000 mg. For example: If a food or supplement provides 200 mg of calcium
per serving, the label would show a 20% DV for calcium (200/1,000 = 20%).
The serving
size on the "Nutrition Facts" panel of foods is based on what people typically
eat -- it is not a recommended amount. The serving size is given at the
top of the panel.
To determine
your calcium intake from a specific food or supplement, identify the serving
size and the % DV on the label. For example, suppose the serving size
listed on a package of frozen chopped broccoli is 1/2 cup and this amount
provides 4% of the calcium DV. If you eat TWICE this amount (1 cup), you
will consume 8% of your daily calcium need.
By adding
up the % DV for calcium in all your foods and supplements, you can learn
whether you reach your goal each day. Also, it's easy to compare the calcium
content of different products by looking at the % DV.
Depending
on your age and such factors as whether you're pregnant or lactating,
you may need MORE or LESS than the 100% DV level of 1,000 mg of calcium
daily. For example: If the calcium recommendation for your age grouping
1,200 mg of calcium, your daily goal should be 120% of the calcium DV.
The following
chart gives the recommended daily calcium and vitamin D intakes for various
ages. Calcium is an important component of bones, and vitamin D is essential
for optimum calcium absorption. These amounts are based on the 1997 recommendations
of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS). Depending on your situation,
your physician may recommend slightly more than these levels. Remember:
The 100% DV for calcium is based on 1,000 mg calcium. For vitamin D, the
100% DV is based on 400 IU vitamin D.
Recommended
Daily Calcium and Vitamin D Intakes
|
|
NOTE:
The NAS (1997) suggests a tolerable upper intake level (UL) for
persons age one and up for calcium no higher than 2,500 mg daily
and for vitamin D no higher than 50 micrograms or 2,000 IU (40 IU
= 1 microgram) daily from foods and supplements combined. UL's have
not been established for individuals below one year of age. However,
unless your physician advises otherwise, the following recommendations
from NAS for the various ages should be sufficient.
|
|
Birth
- 6 months
210 mg calcium (21% DV)
200 IU vitamin D (50% DV)
|
9
- 18 years
1,300 mg calcium (130% DV)
200 IU vitamin D (50% DV) |
6
months - 1 year
270 mg calcium (27% DV)
200 IU vitamin D (50% DV) |
19
- 50 years
1,000 mg calcium (100% DV)
200 IU vitamin D (50% DV) |
1
- 3 years
500 mg calcium (50% DV)
200 IU vitamin D (50% DV) |
51
- 70 years
1,200 mg calcium (120% DV)
400 IU vitamin D (100% DV) |
4
- 8 years
800 mg calcium (80% DV)
200 IU vitamin D (50% DV) |
71
and older
1,200 mg calcium (120% DV)
600 IU vitamin D (150% DV) |
|
Pregnant
& Lactating
|
14
- 18 years
1,300 mg calcium (130% DV)
200 IU vitamin D (50% DV) |
19
- 50 years
1,000 mg calcium (100% DV)
200 IU vitamin D (50% DV) |
Percent
Daily Value For Calcium In Common Foods
To start
you thinking about your dietary calcium intake, here's the approximate
% DV for some common foods. Check actual food labels for a more exact
amount. These amounts are based, in part, on information provided in:
"Calcium! Do You Get It?," by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration/Center
for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition at::
http://vm.cfsan.fda.gov/~dms/ca-toc.html
Grain
Products Group
- Ready-to-eat
cereal, calcium, fortified. Serving size varies; check product label.
Vegetable
Group
- Broccoli
with cheese; 1/2 cup = 20% DV
- Collards;
1/2 cup = 20% DV
- Turnip
greens; 2/3 cup = 15% DV
- Kale;
2/3 cup = 10% DV
- Bok choy;
1/2 cup = 10% DV
- Broccoli;
1 stalk = 6% DV
Fruit Group
- Orange
juice, calcium-fortified; 1 cup = 30% DV
Milk Group
- Yogurt;
8 oz. = 35%
- Milk,
whole, 2%, 1%, skim, chocolate; 1 cup = 30% DV
- Cheese;
1 oz. = 20% DV
- Milk
pudding; 1/2 cup = 10% DV
- Frozen
yogurt; 1/2 cup = 10% DV
- Ice cream;
1/2 cup = 6% DV
- Soy milk,
calcium-fortified; 1 cup = 30% DV
Meat &
Bean Group
- Tofu
prepared with calcium sulfate; 3 oz. = 60% DV
- Baked
beans with sauce; 1/2 cup = 8% DV
- Pork
& beans with sauce; 1/2 cup = 6% DV
The main dietary
sources of vitamin D are fortified milk (400 IU per quart), some fortified
cereals, cold saltwater fish (for example: salmon, halibut, herring, tuna,
oysters and shrimp) and some calcium and vitamin/mineral supplements. Also,
vitamin D can be manufactured in your skin following direct exposure to
sunlight. The amount varies according to such factors as time of day, season
and latitude.
Additional
Dietary Concerns
While dietary
calcium and vitamin D are important in helping prevent or treat osteoporosis,
the following dietary concerns also come into play.
- Food
is best calcium source. Most experts agree food is the best source
of calcium as there may be other factors found in calcium food sources
that also affect use by the body.
- Total
calcium load at one time. Your body can best handle about 500 mg
of calcium at one time, whether from food or supplements. Consume your
calcium foods/supplements throughout the day rather than all at one
time.
- Fiber.
Excessive fiber can interfere with calcium absorption. Dr. Miriam Nelson
(author, Strong Women, Strong Bones) advises that the fiber occurring
in food is probably not a problem. But, if you're sprinkling extra fiber
on food, such as bran on cereal, that might affect calcium absorption.
- Caffeine.
Nelson advises consuming under 400 milligrams of caffeine daily. Excessive
caffeine can increase urinary excretion of calcium. A 6 oz. cup of coffee
has about 100 milligrams caffeine -- the actual amount would depend
on brewing time, etc. Tea, soft drinks and various medications also
can contain caffeine. There are about 40 milligrams of caffeine in 6
oz. of regular brewed tea; green tea may contain less caffeine. Some
soft drinks are comparable to tea in caffeine content. To check the
amount of caffeine in foods, search the USDA Nutrient Database (caffeine
is the last entry at the end of each nutrient report):
www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/foodcomp/index.html
- Excessive
sodium. Excessive sodium can increase urinary calcium excretion.
Go easy on the salt shaker; taste before you salt. Limit the number
of high salt foods. The Food and Nutrition Board recommends sodium be
limited to 2,400 mg daily. The Nutrition Facts panel on foods gives
the sodium content of a food.
- Alcohol.
Consuming more than seven alcoholic drinks per week is associated with
an increased risk of low bone density and of falls and fractures, according
to Nelson. Obviously, you shouldn't drink seven drinks all in the same
day.
- Oxalic
acid. This acid, present in certain foods, such as spinach, chard
and beet greens, binds up the calcium in these foods. However, it doesn't
seem to affect the calcium in foods served with them. These greens are
still good for you and may actually help improve calcium status in other
ways. Also, though chocolate is a source of oxalic acid, it doesn't
seem to tie up the calcium in milk if you drink chocolate milk.
- Soft
drinks. When soft drinks replace milk as a beverage, individuals
are drastically reducing the calcium content of their diets.
- Protein.
Unbalanced, excessively high protein diets could increase urinary excretion
of calcium.
- Soy.
While soy is a nutritious food, not all soy is a source of calcium --
check the "Nutrition Facts" panel on the label for calcium content.
Some
recent research found calcium from calcium-fortified soy milk was
absorbed at only 75% the efficiency of calcium from cow's milk. There
may be some brands not studied that offer a greater absorption rate;
however, at the time of the study, researchers felt their sample was
representative of most of the calcium-fortified soy milk currently
available. (Source: Heaney, RP, et al. Bioavailability of the calcium
in fortified soy imitation milk, with some observations on method.
Am J Clin Nutr 2000; 71: 1166-9.)
These
researchers suggest to get the same amount of usable calcium from
soy milk as you would get from three 8-ounce glasses of cow’s milk,
you will need to drink four 8-ounce glasses of soy milk.
- Fruits
and vegetables. Research by Tucker and colleagues found a diet high
in fruits and vegetables contributed to the maintenance of bone mineral
density. The study found whole grains also helped contribute to potassium
and magnesium. (Source: Tucker, KL, Potassium, magnesium, and fruit
and vegetable intakes are associated with greater bone mineral density
in elderly men and women. Am J Clin Nutr 1999; 69: 727-36.)
The
Food Guide Pyramid recommends 2 to 4 daily servings of fruits and
3 to 5 daily servings of vegetables. Choose from a variety of fruits
and vegetables daily. Try many colors and many kinds.
Help
For The Lactose-Intolerant Person
If you
lack the enzyme needed to digest lactose (milk sugar), you still may be
able to obtain calcium from dairy products. (Source: Suarez, FL, et al.
Lactose maldigestion is not an impediment to the intake of 1,500 mg calcium
daily as dairy products. Am J Clin Nutr 1998; 68: 1118-1122.)
These suggestions
might work for you:
- Eat
small portions of dairy foods. Start by eating small portions of
lactose-containing foods such as milk and gradually increase the serving
size.
- Combine
dairy foods with other foods. Eat dairy foods in combination with
a meal or solid foods.
- Try
non-milk dairy foods. Consider dairy foods other than milk. Many
cheeses (e.g. Cheddar, Swiss, Parmesan) contain less lactose than milk.
Aged cheeses generally have negligible amounts of lactose. Also, many
cultured dairy foods such as yogurt made with live, active bacteria
are generally well tolerated.
- Pre-digest
lactose. When lactose is broken down to its simple sugar components,
glucose and galactose, it may be easier for someone who is lactose intolerant
to use. Consume lactose-hydrolyzed milk and other dairy foods or consider
commercial lactase preparations (capsules, chewable tablets, solutions).
When
You Don't Like To "Drink" Milk
Dairy products
are one of nature's most concentrated dietary sources of calcium. But
you may not like to drink milk. Here are 10 easy tips for including more
milk products in your diet without ever drinking a glass of milk. (Source:
Dairy Council of Nebraska.)
- Make
oatmeal with milk.
- Add milk
to your coffee. (But watch how much caffeinated coffee you drink!)
- Make
soups such as tomato, chowders and cream-type soups with milk instead
of water.
- Add powdered
milk to foods. One tablespoon is equal to 50 milligrams of calcium.
- Make
instant hot cocoa with milk instead of water. Or, when using packets
of hot chocolate, add 1/3 cup of powdered milk which is equivalent to
a cup of milk.
- Serve
milk-based desserts such as puddings, tapioca, frozen yogurt, custard
and ice cream frequently.
- Enjoy
a cup of hot chocolate instead of coffee. An 8-ounce serving of chocolate
milk has only 2 to 7 milligrams of caffeine. Six ounces of coffee has
about 100 milligrams of caffeine. Also, chocolate milk provides, on
average, only about 60 calories more per serving than unflavored milk.
- Use plain
or flavored yogurt as a dressing for fruit salads. For example: Try
Key lime yogurt as a dressing over fruit. Lemon yogurt works with waldorf
salads (typically made with apples and such ingredients as raisins or
grapes, celery and walnuts).
- Top baked
potatoes with yogurt. For added flavor, mix in some snipped fresh chives
or dried chives.
- Enjoy
smoothies for snacks. TIP: blend small frozen fruit pieces (berries
work especially well) with milk or yogurt. Use about a cup of milk or
yogurt; then add 1/2 to 1 cup frozen fruit and blend until smooth and
of desired consistency. Yogurt gives a tangier taste than milk. Or,
use a combination of milk and yogurt. Sweeten to taste with a teaspoon
or two of sugar, honey or jelly; or, use an artificial sweetener. If
desired, add about 1/4 teaspoon vanilla. Drink right away.
You
also can freeze small pieces of fresh or canned fruit until solid.
Freeze for a few hours or overnight on a cookie sheet or in shallow
metal pans -- place fruit in a single layer. Chop larger fruits like
bananas, apricots, etc. into smaller chunks -- about 1/2 to 1 inch.
Transfer frozen fruit to freezer bags for later use or enjoy in a
smoothie right away!
Considerations
When Taking Calcium Supplements
If you're
unable to obtain the recommended amount of calcium from your diet, the
following tips will help you achieve the most benefit from calcium supplements.
Always read the directions carefully. NOTE: Some supplements may require
more than one tablet to achieve the amount of calcium listed in the serving
size.
- Calcium
carbonate. This supplement requires acid to dissolve and for efficient
absorption. As we age, we may not produce as much stomach acid between
meals. It's usually recommended a person take calcium carbonate at mealtime
when the stomach produces more acid.
- Calcium
citrate. This supplement tends to be more expensive than calcium
carbonate but doesn't require stomach acid for absorption. It may be
taken any time; however, your health care provider may recommend a specific
time for you.
- Vitamin
D. Choose a calcium supplement with vitamin D unless you're already
getting vitamin D from other sources. Consider the recommended Daily
Value for vitamin D for your age group. Avoid going over a combined
total of 50 micrograms (2,000 IU) from all calcium supplements, vitamin/mineral
supplements and foods during the day.
- Total
calcium load at one time. Your body can best handle about 500 mg
of calcium at one time, whether from food or supplements. Consume your
calcium supplements and calcium foods throughout the day rather than
all at one time.
- Time
of day. If you take just one supplement, it's probably best to take
it in the evening, according to Nelson. Miriam Nelson recommends taking
calcium carbonate at dinner time and calcium citrate before bed. This
may enhance absorption and utilization.
- Absorption.
If your brand doesn't say it has met USP (United States Pharmacopoeia)
standards, you may want to give it the vinegar test. (NOTE: Applying
for this symbol is voluntary at this time, so there may be many good
products that don't carry it.) Put a tablet in a cup of vinegar and
stir every 5 minutes. It should dissolve in 30 minutes. If it doesn't,
the calcium tablet probably won't dissolve in your stomach, either.
Chewable
and liquid forms should dissolve well as they're already broken down.
- Increase
amount slowly. NOF recommends you increase the amount of calcium
supplements slowly, starting with 500 mg a day for a week and then gradually
adding more. Some types can cause side effects such as gas or constipation
for some people. Increasing fluids and fibrous foods (fruits, vegetables,
whole grains) may help. If you still have problems, switch to another
form of supplement.
- Check
for interactions. NOF advises checking with your physician or pharmacist
about possible interactions with other prescriptions and over-the-counter
drugs you're taking. For example, calcium supplements may reduce the
absorption of the antibiotic tetracycline. If you take a medicine on
an empty stomach, you probably shouldn't take it with a calcium supplement
because it could affect the absorption.
- Food
is still important. Nelson advises high calcium foods also contain
other nutrients that are important in the diet. She recommends you don't
obtain all your calcium from calcium-fortified orange juice and candies.
Putting
It All Together
To apply
this information on calcium and vitamin D:
- List
the foods/supplements and the serving sizes you ate yesterday or in
a typical day.
- Determine
the % DV of calcium and vitamin D they provided, based on the label.
- Adjust
the % DV if you consumed a serving size of food that was different from
the amount listed on the label.
- Total
your amounts and compare your score to the recommended % DV for your
age group.
In assessing
your diet, also consider the other dietary factors and supplement useage
guidelines that influence your bones. Before leaving the topic, remember
weight-bearing exercise, adopting a healthy lifestyle with no smoking or
excessive alcohol use, and getting recommended bone density tests and medications
when appropriate are other important steps in preventing osteoporosis.
A quote
in Dr. Miriam Nelson's book (Strong Women, Strong Bones), taken
from the Massachusetts Osteoporosis Awareness Program, sums it all up:
"Support your bones. They support you."
|